Milmay Homes under $500,000

Milmay Homes under $500,000

Welcome to Milmay, New Jersey—a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Cumberland County. This charming community offers a perfect blend of rural tranquility and suburban convenience, making it an ideal place for families, retirees, and anyone seeking a peaceful lifestyle. With its picturesque landscapes and friendly atmosphere, Milmay embodies the essence of small-town living while still providing easy access to larger urban centers.

One of the most appealing aspects of Milmay is its affordability. For homebuyers looking for value, the area boasts a variety of homes under $500,000. Whether you’re searching for a cozy bungalow, a spacious family home, or a charming cottage, Milmay has something to suit every taste and budget. The local real estate market offers a diverse selection of properties, allowing you to find the perfect place to call home without breaking the bank.

Residents of Milmay enjoy a close-knit community feel, with local events and activities bringing neighbors together. The nearby natural beauty offers ample opportunities for outdoor recreation, from hiking and biking to enjoying leisurely strolls in the fresh air. Plus, the area is conveniently located near major highways, making commuting to nearby cities like Vineland or Millville a breeze.

Explore the charm of Milmay today, and discover why so many are choosing to call this delightful town home. With its affordable housing options and welcoming community, Milmay is ready to welcome you with open arms!

Newest Milmay Homes under $500,000

156 Mcdonald Ave, Milmay

156 Mcdonald Ave, Milmay

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

6+ ACRES!!! FARM!!! PRIVACY!!! ANIMALS!!!! Charming ranch style home featuring: large living room with built in wood burning fireplace,dining area, eat in kitchen with island seating, three great size bedrooms, including the primary bedroom with en-suit, sun room leads to largebackyard overlooking the large wooded area that the owner has intricately fenced in for animals (chickens, pigs, goats, etc ). 6.46 acres offerstons of options. The property currently hosts a multipurpose trail around the entirety of the property great for ATVs, horses or walking. Thefenced in orchard includes perenial fruit trees, vines and bushes as well as asparagus and strawberry plants.The full basement features aRegency wood stove that heats entire home to save on fuel bills

156 Mcdonald Ave, Milmay

Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker Argus Real Estate. Contact:

167 Macdonald Ave, Milmay

167 Macdonald Ave, Milmay

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Discover the potential of this private Milmay property offering nearly 5 acres of land and a brand-new pole barn with electric. With a roof approximately 10 years old, this property is an excellent opportunity for a motivated buyer or investor ready to update and make it their own. Enjoy the privacy, space, and possibilities this unique property has to offer!

167 Macdonald Ave, Milmay

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Prime Realty. Contact:

55 Taylor Ave, Milmay

55 Taylor Ave, Milmay

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Set on approximately 4.82 private acres in Milmay, this spacious single-family home offers a rare combination of comfort, flexibility, and future potential. 55 Taylor Ave features 2 bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms, and approximately 2,174 square feet of living space, two car garage with high ceilings, big unfinished basement, and a layout that provides multiple options for possible additional bedrooms, expanded living areas, or future customization. Inside, the home offers a large eat-in kitchen, a dining area, and a dramatic living room with vaulted ceilings and oversized windows that bring in abundant natural light. Just off the kitchen is the screened in porch- perfect for your morning coffee. Main-floor bedrooms add everyday convenience, while the covered front porch and screened-in side porch create inviting spaces to enjoy the peaceful setting. Upstairs, you’ll find additional flexible space that can serve as a home office, guest area, recreation room, or potentially extra bedrooms. Perhaps you could add a bathroom upstairs for a true primary suite. A full unfinished basement with high ceilings provides excellent storage, workspace, or future finishing possibilities. Outside, the property continues to impress with a circular driveway, a two-car garage, and a beautiful lot that offers privacy, open space, and endless possibilities for outdoor enjoyment. This stunning home is an exceptional opportunity for buyers seeking acreage, ample square footage, and a home with room to grow.

55 Taylor Ave, Milmay

Listing courtesy of BHHS Fox & Roach-Washington-Gloucester. Contact:

Start Your Search

Shannon Ergott

Hi, I’m Shannon, a lifelong Pennsylvania resident with a deep appreciation for the communities, neighborhoods, and lifestyles that make this region such a wonderful place to call home.   Drawing on more than a decade of experience as a business owner, I bring strong marketing skills, attention to detail, and a client-focused approach to my real estate career. My background has taught me the value of exceptional customer service, clear communication, and building lasting relationships based on trust and integrity.   I am deeply involved in every stage of the buying and selling process. From preparing your home for the market to personally creating professional photography and visual marketing materials, I ensure each property is presented thoughtfully and strategically to attract qualified buyers. This hands-on approach allows me to maintain exceptional quality and consistency while helping my clients stand out in today’s competitive market.   Whether you’re buying your first home, searching for your next home, or preparing to sell, I am committed to providing personalized service and trusted guidance every step of the way. I understand that buying or selling a home is one of life’s most significant financial and emotional decisions, and my goal is to make the process as smooth, informed, and stress-free as possible.   By combining local market knowledge with creative marketing strategies and a dedication to client success, I strive to help buyers and sellers achieve their real estate goals with confidence.

Learn More