Bennington Homes under $500,000

Bennington Homes under $500,000

Welcome to Bennington, a charming subdivision nestled in the heart of Carlisle, Pennsylvania, within the picturesque Cumberland County. This vibrant community offers a perfect blend of suburban tranquility and modern convenience, making it an ideal place for families, young professionals, and retirees alike.

Bennington is characterized by its friendly atmosphere and attractive streetscapes, featuring well-maintained homes that exude warmth and character. With a variety of architectural styles, residents can find everything from classic single-family homes to contemporary designs, all under the appealing price point of $500,000. This affordability makes Bennington an attractive option for first-time homebuyers or those looking to downsize without compromising on quality or comfort.

The community is not just about beautiful homes; it also boasts easy access to local amenities, including parks, shopping centers, and top-rated schools. Families will appreciate the nearby recreational opportunities, with lush green spaces perfect for picnics, walking trails, and playgrounds for the little ones. Additionally, the proximity to Carlisle's bustling downtown area allows residents to enjoy a variety of dining, entertainment, and cultural experiences.

Living in Bennington means enjoying a peaceful suburban lifestyle while being just a short drive away from larger urban centers. Whether you’re looking for a cozy starter home or a spacious residence for your growing family, Bennington has something for everyone. Discover the charm and community spirit of Bennington—your dream home awaits!

Newest Bennington Homes under $500,000

11 Bennington Way, Carlisle
$439,000
5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
Enjoy the fresh feel of newer construction with owner-added upgrades already in place. Built in 2022, this home in Carlisle’s Bennington community features updated paint throughout—a fresh, neutral blank slate ready for your personal style—along with new first-floor carpeting and professionally cleaned interiors. Four upstairs bedrooms, 2.5 baths, finished lower-level recreation space, and an attached two-car garage provide generous living space on a 0.28-acre lot. The open main level connects the living and dining areas with a kitchen featuring upgraded cabinetry and countertops. Upstairs, the primary suite includes a private bath and walk-in closet. The partially finished basement offers flexible space for recreation, hobbies, or a home office, plus storage and room for future expansion. An owner-added Trex composite deck creates an inviting setting for outdoor dining and relaxing. Additional upgrades include five ceiling fans, a hot-water recirculation system for faster hot water at the taps, and decorative stone landscaping with black steel edging. Natural-gas heating, central air conditioning, and public water and sewer provide everyday convenience. Approximately two miles from historic downtown Carlisle, the home puts independent restaurants, coffee shops, boutiques, galleries, and Farmers on the Square within easy reach. Dickinson College, the Carlisle Theatre, local parks, shopping, and Carlisle Barracks are nearby, with convenient access to I-81 and the Pennsylvania Turnpike for travel to Harrisburg and beyond.

11 Bennington Way, Carlisle

Listing courtesy of Coldwell Banker Realty. Contact:

54 Bennington Way, Carlisle
$399,375
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
This newly constructed residential property in the Bennington subdivision offers a blend of modern design and functional living. Completed in 2026, the interior boasts four spacious bedrooms and two and a half bathrooms, including a primary suite and walk-in closet. Key interior highlights include kitchen cabinet crown moldings, a dedicated dining area, and a well-appointed kitchen equipped with essential appliances such as a refrigerator, built-in microwave, electric oven/range, dishwasher, and disposal. The main floor laundry hookups enhance convenience, while insulated, low-E windows ensure energy efficiency. A rough in basement bathroom is already included. Making a future finished basement easier. The property is situated on a 0.24-acre lot, complemented by a front-entry attached garage and driveway for ample parking. Outdoor living is enhanced with inviting deck and porch, perfect for relaxation.

54 Bennington Way, Carlisle

Listing courtesy of Carper Realty, LLC. Contact:

36 Bennington Way, Carlisle
$489,755
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
**Ready for October Close!** Finished basement included! The Henley by D.R. Horton is a new construction home plan Lot 107 featuring 2,910 square feet of open living space, 4 large bedrooms, 2.5 baths and a bonus upstairs living space added on the second floor. Partially finished basement storage rooms and 3 pieces rough in for future bathroom. The Henley features a staircase situated away from foyer for convenience and privacy, as well as a wonderful study or flex room, you decide how it's used! The kitchen is well appointed with beautiful cabinetry, a large pantry, stainless steel appliances and a built-in island with ample seating space. The entry from the garage has a large drop zone area conveniently located for coats and jackets. Enjoy the added convenience of this home’s spacious laundry room located on the second floor. Ask about our great incentives, to help you get into a brand new home!

36 Bennington Way, Carlisle

Listing courtesy of D.R. Horton Realty of Pennsylvania. Contact:

41 Bennington Way, Carlisle
$389,990
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Check out this beautiful 1 level living floorplan, the Neuville. This home boasts 4 bedrooms, 2 bath, with open concept living. The large island looks into your great room and dining area, perfect for entertaining or just being near family and friends. With a large pantry, you won't run out of storage for appliances and pantry items. This new construction home comes with a 1 year cosmetic warranty, 2 year mechanical and 10 year structural. Introducing Bennington, a new single family home community consisting of 68 homes coming soon to Carlisle, Pennsylvania. Bennington is about 2 miles from the heart of Carlisle, and provides accessibility to nearby interstates and commuter routes. Additionally, residents enjoy quick access to local restaurants, shopping, art galleries, and the tree-lined streets of downtown Carlisle. For those with an affinity for the outdoors, the Cumberland Valley is also home to scenic state parks and golf courses.

41 Bennington Way, Carlisle

Listing courtesy of D.R. Horton Realty of Pennsylvania. Contact:

40 Bennington Way, Carlisle
$459,990
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
MOVE-IN-READY!! The Galen by D.R. Horton is a stunning new construction home plan featuring 2,795 square feet of living space, 4 bedrooms, 2.5 baths and a 2-car garage. The Galen is popular for a reason! Off the foyer is the flex room, use this space can be used as a dining room, home office or children’s play area! The kitchen featuring a large, modern island opens up to the dining area and great room, you will never have to miss a beat. Upstairs, the four bedrooms provide enough space for everyone, and the second-floor laundry room simplifies an everyday chore! The finished basement is great for additional storage or as a rec room to entertain friends and family!

40 Bennington Way, Carlisle

Listing courtesy of D.R. Horton Realty of Pennsylvania. Contact:

43 Bennington Way, Carlisle
$469,755
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
QUICK MOVE IN!! The Henley by D.R. Horton is a new construction home plan Lot 25 featuring 2,600 square feet of open living space, 4 large bedrooms, 2.5 baths and a bonus upstairs living space added on the second floor. Partially finished basement storage rooms and 3 pieces rough in for future bathroom. The Henley features a staircase situated away from foyer for convenience and privacy, as well as a wonderful study or flex room, you decide how it's used! The kitchen is well appointed with beautiful cabinetry, a large pantry, stainless steel appliances and a built-in island with ample seating space. The entry from the garage has a large drop zone area conveniently located for coats and jackets. Enjoy the added convenience of this home’s spacious laundry room located on the second floor. Ask about our great incentives, to help you get into a brand new home!

43 Bennington Way, Carlisle

Listing courtesy of D.R. Horton Realty of Pennsylvania. Contact:

49 Bennington Way, Carlisle
$449,755
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
QUICK MOVE IN!!! The Penwell by D.R. Horton is a new construction, two-story home plan featuring 2,148 sq.ft. of open living space with 4 bedrooms, 2.5 bathrooms and a 2-car garage. The main level features a chef-inspired kitchen with an oversized island and walk-in pantry, as well as a flex room that’s ideal for a formal dining room or home office, you decide how it’s used! The kitchen opens onto a spacious living room, perfect for the entertainer. The owner’s suite on the second level offers a luxurious owner’s bath with a separate shower, private bathroom, and large walk-in closet. There are also 3 additional bedrooms, a full bathroom, a walk-in laundry room on the second level. The finished basement is great for additional storage or more space to entertain friends and family! Introducing Bennington, a new single family home community consisting of 68 homes coming soon to Carlisle, Pennsylvania. Bennington is about 2 miles from the heart of Carlisle, and provides accessibility to nearby interstates and commuter routes. Additionally, residents enjoy quick access to local restaurants, shopping, art galleries, and the tree-lined streets of downtown Carlisle. For those with an affinity for the outdoors, the Cumberland Valley is also home to scenic state parks and golf courses.

49 Bennington Way, Carlisle

Listing courtesy of D.R. Horton Realty of Pennsylvania. Contact:

83 Bennington Way, Carlisle
$475,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
Welcome to 83 Bennington Way, Carlisle, PA—a beautiful two-story home offering 2,046 square feet of spacious living in a desirable and welcoming neighborhood. This well-designed residence features 4 bedrooms and 2.5 bathrooms, providing plenty of space and comfort for a growing family. The thoughtful layout offers a perfect balance of open living areas and private spaces, making it ideal for both everyday living and entertaining. Located in a nice, family-friendly community, this home delivers both comfort and convenience, with easy access to nearby schools, shopping, and major routes. It’s a wonderful opportunity to enjoy modern living in a peaceful and established neighborhood. A perfect place to call home for your growing family!

83 Bennington Way, Carlisle

Listing courtesy of Onest Real Estate. Contact:

69 Bennington Way, Carlisle
$469,900
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
Welcome to this beautifully newly built 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath home, completed in 2023 and now on the market! All four bedrooms are conveniently located upstairs, offering comfort and privacy. This spacious home features a dining area, office room, flex room, living room, and a stunning kitchen with an island perfect for gathering and entertaining. With its warm and welcoming layout, this home is ready for new homeowners to make it their dream home.

69 Bennington Way, Carlisle

Listing courtesy of Ghimire Homes. Contact:

Start Your Search